Wind, Water, and Solar Are Not Enough

Wind, Water, and Solar Are Not Enough2018-11-17T16:55:53+00:00

We cannot get all the electricity we need from renewables.

A “renewables only” scenario is unrealistic and not supported by science.

“While it is theoretically possible to rely primarily (or even entirely) on variable renewable energy resources such as wind and solar, it would be signicantly more challenging and costly than pathways that employ a diverse portfolio of resources.”

– Jesse Jenkins and Samuel Thernstrom, 2017

  • In spite of 2 decades of public and private support, wind produced less than 6.3% of U.S. electricity in 2016; solar less than 1.3%

  • Hydroelectric power is already close to capacity in the northern hemisphere.

Germany is an example of a failed 100% renewables policy.

Germany has aggressively expanded wind and solar but it is not on track to reach its emissions goals.

“Germany has invested hundreds of billions to promote renewable energy sources. Yet emissions have been dropping slower than thought, because Germany is shutting down nuclear and is therefore depending more on its coal power.”

– Rauli Partanen, 2017

“Coal is the largest domestically-produced source of power in Germany, despite a tremendous surge in renewables over the last ten years. As a result, the country’s CO2 emissions have not declined much.”

– Dr. James Conca, Forbes, 2017

Wind and solar are intermittent and require back-up.

Links We Like

“Policy makers should treat with caution any visions of a rapid, reliable, and low-cost transition to entire energy systems that rely almost exclusively on wind, solar, and hydroelectric power.”

– Clack, et. al., PNAS, 2017

“German emissions increased in 2016 for a second year in a row as a result of the country closing one of its nuclear plants and replacing it with coal and natural gas”

– Environmental Progress, 2017

“With the planet warming and carbon dioxide emissions rising faster than ever, we cannot afford to turn away from any technology that has the potential to displace a large fraction of our carbon emissions…The time has come for a fresh approach to nuclear power in the 21st century.”

– Emanuel, Hansen, Caldeira, and Wigley